Recently, a few Swathmore college students set out to put a spotlight on inadequacies of the country’s voting machines. They had come across 15,000 email messages and memos presumed leaked or stolen from Diebold Election Systems, makers of most of our election machines. In short, these messages centered around flaws in the software as well as security issues.
Remembering the events of the 2000 presidential election, the students decided to post the files on the internet. While noble, the actions broke the 1998 Digital Millenium Copyright Act. The D.M.C.A belongs to a group of recent laws aimed at regulating intellectual property. The act was engineered to protect copyrighted material on the web by making Internet service providers responsible for what its users post. It’s quite simple, any aggrieved party threatens a lawsuit, the provider, to avoid liability removes the material, and everyone is happy. This gives private parties almost absolute control over much of the information published online.
The Swathmore students, shortly after posting the memos, were charged with Copyright infringement by an angry Diebold. Diebold insisted the material be removed from the site on the college’s server. Swathmore made no argument and complied. That is the D.M.A.C. in all it’s glory.
While Diebold was in the right, legally, the students persistence and negative publicity forced the company to drop their lawsuit. While the memos are now on the internet, there are quite a few fears from proponents of free speech on the net.
The days of the “Wide Open Range” that was the Interet, are coming to a close and more and more is guarded. Everything from girl scouts attacked for singing copyrighted songs around the campfire to authors and now proposed patents on genes are among the new wave of insanity.
No one will argue that the film industry and the music industry are among the largest groups focused on protecting their enterprise from illegal downloads. Everyone does it, but soon, thanks to successful lobbying, the companies will be able to lengthen copyright terms thereby controlling more and more.